Saturday, 12 September 2009

Teachers on Screen

Pierre Dulaine (Antonio Banderas)
Take the Lead (2006)
Dir. Liz Friedlander

In this film Mr. Dulaine, or Pierre as he is known to his students, is portrayed as being a talented individual with a passion for his subject. By being on first name terms with his class, he is removing a barrier that may attract strong anti-establishment and rebellious feelings amongst a class that already has demonstrated issues with formal schooling. Through the film he displays an unwavering belief that he can influence the lives of his students through his subject and a high level of self-belief in his own methods. He is portrayed in much the same way as Miss Johnson in Dangerous Minds (Dir. John N Smith, 1995) as being determined to reach his students and as willing to adapt his approach to the class due to their confrontational nature and disinterest in his subject. By using giving the students an introduction as to why they are studying the subject, his reasons for teaching, and a series of demonstrations and practical lessons, he engages the class on a number of levels at once. Through this change in techniques, he begins to build a rapport with the student and an underlying element of trust begins to grow. This rapport allows him to maintain a quiet authority over his students and allows him to adopt a much firmer, stricter tone to halt any interruption or distraction to the whole class learning. Early on he sets his students an achievable target and goal for them to work towards. Through individual encouragement and group praise the confidence of the learners begins to grow rapidly. This encouragement and praise is counterbalanced by constructive criticism and feedback that never allows the student to grow complacent and makes them strive to achieve their goals. Whilst this is happening, it is shown that Pierre is not afraid to take onboard ideas that the students put forward. This again builds trust as the students are not afraid to take positive control over their own learning and do not feel that there is a boundary between their ideas and those of their teacher.

Mr. Phillotson (Liam Cunningham)
Jude (1996)
Dir. Michael Winterbottom

By contrast the depiction of the teacher in Jude is one that is dated due to the setting of the film. Although the teaching methods and style employed is held rigidly by the time period, the attitude and motivation behind the teacher remains similar. Students were required to sit and listen intently whilst the teacher distributed information aurally. Students are then meant to absorb subject knowledge by osmosis, memorising all the necessary information and reciting when asked. From the short display in the film, this method supposedly engaged the entire class. However this method seems more of a memory test and completely out-dated by today’s modern standards. However from what we learn of the character we can see that his attitudes towards students are the same. He gives the character of Jude an inspirational speech about how you need to follow the path of academia in order to gain success in life and change your future. This motivation is then shown to affect Jude throughout his life, and influence him on all his choices.

No comments:

Post a Comment